Why is it so difficult for Gov. Doug Ducey to support dreamers? Everyone else does
Opinion: Touting economic ties between Mexico and Arizona is great, but Ducey should also embrace immigrants in Arizona – many of whom are from Mexico.
Gov. Doug Ducey doesn’t want any credit for ending his legal fight against letting Arizona "dreamers" get their driver licenses. And there may be a good reason for it.
Turns out the Republican governor didn’t really have a good case, since a federal judge had already sided with dreamers and the U.S. Supreme Court had declined to consider it.
The legal fight stems from a 2012 executive order by former Gov. Jan Brewer targeting dreamers, undocumented immigrants protected from deportation by former President Barack Obama’s program known as DACA.
But the Ducey administration refused to give up Brewer's fight against those protected from deportation, including victims of domestic violence. A federal judge again slapped Arizona down.
It is a victory, and I'll give Ducey credit
That bring us to this week. The Arizona Department of Transportation opted against appealing the latest federal ruling, and so DACA recipients are free to keep their drivers licenses, reported Howard Fischer of Capitol Media Services.
That means a sigh of relief for Arizonans because the roads are a little safer with licensed dreamers.
“It’s a victory,” said Karina Ruiz, who’s among the more than 28,000 dreamers living in the state and the director of the Arizona Dream Act Coalition. “We’ll take it.”
I’ll join that victory lap, and I’ll even give Ducey credit – if nothing else because he finally stopped wasting taxpayers’ money appealing a senseless crusade against young immigrants.
If he likes Mexico, why not Mexicans?
It really is a good thing to put this legal fight behind us. But why is Ducey so meticulously distancing himself from this decision?
His spokesman, Patrick Ptak, said ADOT “directed the litigation, including the decision to settle it.”
Let's get real. ADOT is a state agency that Ducey oversees, so nobody believes they’d take any action without the governor’s blessing.
“We've worked hard to make Arizona a welcoming place for all and will continue to do so,’’ Ptak added without answering direct questions about Ducey's stance on years of litigation.
That kind of elusive rhetoric is discouraging because I had hoped that the governor who touts Mexico as a key economic trading partner and boasts about his friendship with politicians south of the border would now openly embrace immigrants in Arizona – many of whom are from Mexico.
But, sadly, that doesn’t appear to be the case, even now that he is serving his second term and doesn’t have to face the conservative electorate that put him in office in the first place.
Will Ducey at least support this?
Ducey really is an enigma. He’s publicly polite and gracious to immigrants, carefully choosing his words. By many accounts he has put the brakes on anti-immigrant bills since the dark days of Brewer’s era. And he goes all-out luring Mexican business to Arizona.
Yet, he fights the very immigrants that come from Mexico, exploits fears of a U.S.-Mexico border invasion to get re-elected, praises the presidential pardon of former Sheriff Joe Arpaio and refuses to denounce president Donald Trump’s racial divisiveness.
Should Latinos and immigrants still give him the benefit of the doubt against this backdrop? Of course.
Ducey can and should have a change of heart. He can show it by supporting separate legislative efforts to let dreamers get in-state college tuition and rid of the remnants of the infamous Senate Bill 1070.
MORE FROM DIAZ:
- MLK's legacy is the modern radical left
- Proposed education tax hike is an insult to Latinos
- A border crisis? Yes. But it's not Trump's wall of lies